How often did holding an Aggressive Hybrid fund for a long stretch end in a loss? This study looked at daily rolling windows of Direct Growth schemes and counted. The answer changes sharply with the holding period.
Key Takeaways
- 0.0% loss probability at 10Y: across 22,955 daily rolling windows across 20 Direct Growth schemes, no 10-year window ended below zero.
- Worst 10-year CAGR was +1.79%, and the median was 13.47%.
- Loss probability fell with longer holding periods: 13.75% at 1Y, 2.65% at 3Y, 1.31% at 5Y, 0.63% at 7Y and 0.0% at 10Y.
- Caveats matter: the data covers currently active schemes only (survivorship bias), and past distributions are not indicative of future results.
What Was Measured
Every figure here is a lump-sum, point-to-point annualised return (CAGR). SIP returns are not covered. The study used Direct plans, Growth option, one series per scheme, from daily NAV history that has been internally validated. The data starts on 2013-01-01, when Direct plans launched.
A rolling window means starting on a given day and measuring the return over the next N years, then repeating for every following day. Pooling those windows across schemes gives a large sample.
Loss Probability by Holding Period
| Holding period | Daily rolling windows | Direct Growth schemes | Loss probability | Median CAGR | Worst CAGR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1Y | 110,042 | 30 | 13.75% | 11.08% | -39.65% |
| 3Y | 88,112 | 30 | 2.65% | 14.13% | -16.75% |
| 5Y | 66,890 | 27 | 1.31% | 13.45% | -7.87% |
| 7Y | 47,606 | 26 | 0.63% | 12.88% | -8.18% |
| 10Y | 22,955 | 20 | 0.0% | 13.47% | +1.79% |
The loss probability fell at each longer holding period in the observed windows. The 10Y horizon is the only one where no window ended in a loss.
How Wide Were the Outcomes?
Loss probability is one number. The spread of outcomes tells more of the story.
| Holding period | 5th percentile | 95th percentile | Standard deviation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1Y | -5.97% | 48.22% | 16.48 |
| 3Y | 2.55% | 24.16% | 6.32 |
| 5Y | 5.34% | 22.2% | 5.2 |
| 7Y | 8.83% | 17.9% | 3.07 |
| 10Y | 9.67% | 17.41% | 2.56 |
At 1Y the range ran from a worst result of -39.65% (window 2019-03-23 to 2020-03-23) to a best of 106.15%. At 10Y the 5th to 95th percentile band was 9.67% to 17.41%. Medians looked similar across horizons. What narrowed was the range around them.
Did Windows Beat Inflation?
Using the RBI upper tolerance band of 6.0% as a threshold, the share of windows that beat it was 67.26% at 1Y, 90.3% at 3Y, 93.79% at 5Y, 98.43% at 7Y and 98.78% at 10Y. A 0.0% loss probability at 10Y therefore did not mean every window cleared 6.0%.
Why the 0.0% Needs Context
- Survivorship bias: only currently active schemes are included. Closed or merged schemes are excluded, which can flatter historical results.
- Narrow 10Y start range: all 10Y windows start between 2013-01-01 and 2016-10-01. They overlap heavily, so 22,955 windows are not 22,955 independent experiments.
- Early start years carried the losses at shorter horizons: at 5Y, windows starting in 2013, 2014 and 2015 held all the non-zero loss figures (6.52%, 3.82% and 4.58%). At 7Y, only 2013 starts were non-zero (5.5%).
- Category membership: the label reflects today's SEBI classification, and earlier windows use today's membership.
- Other holding periods were not tested.
- Pre-tax figures: the snapshot notes that long-term capital gains on equity mutual funds held over 1 year are taxed at 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh per financial year. Short-term gains on holdings up to 1 year are taxed at 20%. The returns above do not reflect tax.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the loss probability for Aggressive Hybrid funds over 10 years?
It was 0.0% across 22,955 daily rolling windows across 20 Direct Growth schemes. The worst 10-year CAGR in those windows was +1.79%, and the median was 13.47%.
How does loss probability change with holding period?
In the observed windows, it fell from 13.75% at 1Y to 2.65% at 3Y, 1.31% at 5Y, 0.63% at 7Y and 0.0% at 10Y. These are lump-sum, point-to-point returns.
Does a 0.0% loss probability mean a loss cannot happen?
No. It describes the sampled windows only. The universe excludes closed or merged schemes, all 10Y windows start between 2013-01-01 and 2016-10-01, and past distributions are not indicative of future results.
Do these numbers apply to SIP investing?
No. Every statistic here is a lump-sum, point-to-point return. SIP returns were not measured.
Which schemes and plans were included?
Direct plan, Growth option, one series per scheme, for currently active schemes only. The data window starts on 2013-01-01, and the data is internally validated.
This is educational content, not investment advice; consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser.
